Thank you for everything you write on this topic. Social transition is a dangerous game and people so rarely realize this; it’s not something that one can just so easily stop/walk away from, especially when you truly believe that you’re in the wrong body and that disguising yourself is the only way to be happy... As a teen especially. I was exactly 18 when I started testosterone, only a few days after my birthday and still in high school. Fridays were for taking math tests and testosterone shots. At 12, I learned to call my breasts “man boobs/moobs” which really messed up my self-image; I’m sure you experienced similar. The damage done to them when I was a child made a mastectomy “make sense” to me as an adult. The ideology is dangerous. Every step of this process is dangerous to the mind.
God bless you AND your parents. Trans ideology is a 1st world issue, because elsewhere they have more serious problems like extreme poverty and starvation and disease. You make a very clear and stark point: wr must continue this fight yo protect our children and youth, despite the short-term successes of today.
This is a brilliant essay. Thank you so much for your courage on speaking out about this issue with both passion AND compassion. I am hoping more and more people in charge are able to read cogent analyses and personal stories like this to inform how youth are treated in the future.
This is hilarious: “I spent hours on social media engaging in fruitless debates with my terrorist-supporting leftist American friends back home. As a result, the algorithms began to shift the content I was seeing and I found myself in right-wing internet spaces.” There’s no telling where the algorithms will take us!
And I do wish the algorithms could be changed to show us a wider variety of content, rather than funnel us into more and more narrowly-focused material similar to (or ideologically-allied with) what we’re already looking at!
In some cases—like yours—the algorithms may help people broaden their horizons; but more often, they reinforce the paths that we’re already on and the bubbles that we’re already starting to live in. And—as we now know—this is especially harmful to kids.
Thank you for this essay, Maia! But wait, what... you "knew" at 12 that small breasts could be removed by liposuction? On a female? Were you told this from a medical professional? What of all the milk glands in breasts? I have never heard of such a thing, and wonder if it was just medical propaganda that you are referring to?
It was the internet lol. Doctors appeared on documentaries and trans activists talked about this. I was fascinated by the topic and learned everything there was to know about it. The risks were discussed very poorly
You sound very impressionable. Your iPad convinces you that you are trans. Having to go into a bomb shelter flattened a very complicated conflict into a simple matter of good vs evil.
Maia...excellent post. I had often thought about the social aspect of this and how it's the 'gateway drug' for what follows. It is every bit as dangerous and bless your parents and the storm they must've endured to refuse to affirm their beautiful daughter. One this might begin to change is to get the head of the snake which are the 'credentialled' professionals who tell both parents and children this is the only path. They have enormous societal influence. You (and Rob Henderson where I first heard the term) are correct in calling this a luxury belief. It is borne out of (Western) societies that are extremely narcissistic and wealthy. Remove those two elements from society and things may shift. Thanks for your testimonial.
It’s interesting that you enjoyed living as an Orthodox man while in Israel! Have you now sought out a more egalitarian practice of Judaism—one where you can participate fully in services (be counted in a minyan, be called to the Torah, etc.), without presenting as male?
And might it be that what attracted you to transitioning in the first place was that you didn’t like the role the more traditionalist forms of your religion had assigned you as a woman?
(And, I wonder, might this sort of issue—resistance to traditional sex roles—also be a factor for other people?)
Thanks for your writing. I am happy to know about your parents doing their best to support your growth without falling into the affirmation only trap. It is very hard to walk a kid back from the trans ledge, but Genepect and other resources exist to help families now, unlike ten years ago.
Thank you for everything you write on this topic. Social transition is a dangerous game and people so rarely realize this; it’s not something that one can just so easily stop/walk away from, especially when you truly believe that you’re in the wrong body and that disguising yourself is the only way to be happy... As a teen especially. I was exactly 18 when I started testosterone, only a few days after my birthday and still in high school. Fridays were for taking math tests and testosterone shots. At 12, I learned to call my breasts “man boobs/moobs” which really messed up my self-image; I’m sure you experienced similar. The damage done to them when I was a child made a mastectomy “make sense” to me as an adult. The ideology is dangerous. Every step of this process is dangerous to the mind.
God bless you AND your parents. Trans ideology is a 1st world issue, because elsewhere they have more serious problems like extreme poverty and starvation and disease. You make a very clear and stark point: wr must continue this fight yo protect our children and youth, despite the short-term successes of today.
Absolutely!
This is such an intelligent, well researched and compassionate essay. From the bottom of my heart I thank you for speaking out. You are courageous.
I appreciate that!
This is a brilliant essay. Thank you so much for your courage on speaking out about this issue with both passion AND compassion. I am hoping more and more people in charge are able to read cogent analyses and personal stories like this to inform how youth are treated in the future.
I appreciate that!
This is hilarious: “I spent hours on social media engaging in fruitless debates with my terrorist-supporting leftist American friends back home. As a result, the algorithms began to shift the content I was seeing and I found myself in right-wing internet spaces.” There’s no telling where the algorithms will take us!
And I do wish the algorithms could be changed to show us a wider variety of content, rather than funnel us into more and more narrowly-focused material similar to (or ideologically-allied with) what we’re already looking at!
In some cases—like yours—the algorithms may help people broaden their horizons; but more often, they reinforce the paths that we’re already on and the bubbles that we’re already starting to live in. And—as we now know—this is especially harmful to kids.
Thank you for this essay, Maia! But wait, what... you "knew" at 12 that small breasts could be removed by liposuction? On a female? Were you told this from a medical professional? What of all the milk glands in breasts? I have never heard of such a thing, and wonder if it was just medical propaganda that you are referring to?
It was the internet lol. Doctors appeared on documentaries and trans activists talked about this. I was fascinated by the topic and learned everything there was to know about it. The risks were discussed very poorly
So insightful! Thank you.
Thank you!
You sound very impressionable. Your iPad convinces you that you are trans. Having to go into a bomb shelter flattened a very complicated conflict into a simple matter of good vs evil.
Maia...excellent post. I had often thought about the social aspect of this and how it's the 'gateway drug' for what follows. It is every bit as dangerous and bless your parents and the storm they must've endured to refuse to affirm their beautiful daughter. One this might begin to change is to get the head of the snake which are the 'credentialled' professionals who tell both parents and children this is the only path. They have enormous societal influence. You (and Rob Henderson where I first heard the term) are correct in calling this a luxury belief. It is borne out of (Western) societies that are extremely narcissistic and wealthy. Remove those two elements from society and things may shift. Thanks for your testimonial.
Do you have suggestions for de-radicalization?
I was wondering the same - thanks for asking!
It’s interesting that you enjoyed living as an Orthodox man while in Israel! Have you now sought out a more egalitarian practice of Judaism—one where you can participate fully in services (be counted in a minyan, be called to the Torah, etc.), without presenting as male?
And might it be that what attracted you to transitioning in the first place was that you didn’t like the role the more traditionalist forms of your religion had assigned you as a woman?
(And, I wonder, might this sort of issue—resistance to traditional sex roles—also be a factor for other people?)
You are a brave young woman! And you are 💯 on that we have not addressed the off-ramps for these poor children and young adults. Keep it up!! 🙏🙏♥️♥️
Thanks for your writing. I am happy to know about your parents doing their best to support your growth without falling into the affirmation only trap. It is very hard to walk a kid back from the trans ledge, but Genepect and other resources exist to help families now, unlike ten years ago.
Brilliant, Maia. Thank you.
Thank you for sharing your experience. This is an honest, thoughtful, and courageous essay.
You have added important ideas to the current conversation -- thank you.