Discussion about this post

User's avatar
Hippiesq's avatar

There are a million questions raised by Jazz Jennings, the Dutch Protocol, and this whole trend toward social and medical transition. I'll focus in on one. Why didn't people realize what was happening to Jazz even though it was all done in plain sight?

Perhaps because it was done in plain sight, people thought it must have been fine. But that's only part of the answer. There are several more parts. We as a society were coming to a point of realization about how badly we had treated homosexuality, and growing to regret it, not wanting to make the same mistakes again. Although same-sex attraction and social and medical transition are clearly distinguishable and, ironically, it is pre-gay boys who are most likely to be transitioned as children, people don't stop and think. They just assume it's all the same thing - people born different, who have different needs. They don't question the idea that some children NEED to be referred to and treated as if they are the opposite sex to be happy and then need to be chemically and/or surgically altered to appear the opposite sex to be happy.

But there's more. Something I've been thinking about lately - the optics. When we watch movies about Nazis, or about slavery, what do we see? We see terrified victims and evil-doers abusing them. We can't understand how anyone ever allowed this to happen. But look at the photos of Jazz - all smiles. Look at the videos of parents hugging their "trans-girls" and "trans-boys," the love and care these children are receiving. Photos of Dr. Sidhbh Gallagher and the young patients whose breasts she just lopped off show a caring physician and her satisfied customers. People aren't seeing past the veneer of kindness to the cruelty beneath it.

So, in short, people are thinking on the most shallow level, thinking they see kindness when what is being done is obviously horribly detrimental. People are making a quick leap to same-sex attraction and assuming transition is the same, again without thinking any further. People think somebody must know what they're doing or why else would these children need to be chemically and surgically altered. Plus, the kids seem so happy. They aren't thinking to the next step, where they would realize that sometimes medical scandals occur and people don't actually do the right thing. Sometimes horrible things happen and it's up to us to stop them. And sometimes the victims of cruelty don't realize they're victims, not right away. Sometimes it takes years.

Thankfully, people like you, Maia, are here to force the world to think deeper and come to the horrifying realization that something awful is occurring.

Jasonrozelaar@gmail.com's avatar

you are getting very close to explaining one of the major factors in the development of this industry.

i am english but have amercian relatives. when we get together and talk, the huge gulf in our attitudes to medication and healthcare becomes stark. while virtually none of the enlgish side of the family take any medication, every single one of the adults from the usa are on at least one kind of pill, many have multiple pills per day.

it is my view that the american healthcare industry has instilled this concept into public consciousness as entirely normal. hence, when jazz was young, his parents, along with the medical healthcare industry needed to at least have an option of some kind of treatment for what is so obviously at best, a mental health issue.

52 more comments...

Ready for more?